The ashtkoot guna milan score is 24.5 which is higher than 18 that is require for marriage. There is 2-12 Bhakoot dosha as the Boy is Aries and the Girl is Pisces. Bhakkot dosha brings ego problems and temperament problems. 2-12 is related to finances and health. It is not auspicious.
Regarding mangal dosha we see that In the birth chart of aatmy Mars is placed in the eighth house from the lagna while in the Moon chart Mars is placed in sixth house from the Moon. Hence aatmy is Mangalik from the Birth Chart but not from the Moon Chart. In the birth chart of Girl Mars is placed in the seventh house from the lagna while in the Moon chart Mars is placed in tenth house from the Moon. Hence Girl is Mangalik from the Birth Chart but not from the Moon Chart.
As both charts have Mangal dosha therefore they are compatible on that front.
Blessings,
Navneet Khanna
Astrologer