The problem with your knowledge in Astrology is that you are taking things for granted. How are you so sure that the details of father given by the boy are accurate. Only his mother would be able to answer it. If the question was raised by his mother, you could have answered her the possible reasons. I had many such instances of similar consultation in my five decades of experience in the field. Don’t shoot the gun without knowing how to hold it properly.
Online Magazine on Vedic Astrology