Looking at both the horoscopes we see that In the birth chart of Boy Mars is placed in the eighth house from the lagna while in the Moon chart Mars is placed in eleventh house from the Moon. Hence Boy is Mangalik from the Birth Chart but not from the Moon Chart.
In the birth chart of Girl Mars is placed in the eighth house from the lagna while in the Moon chart Mars is placed in first house from the Moon. Hence Girl is Mangalik from the Birth Chart and also Chandra Mangalik from the Moon Chart.
As both charts have strong mangal dosha they are compatible on this front.
Navneetji, Thank you so very much Sir for your feedback and details. Just one small point pls. Since the Girl is Manglik from both Birth and Moon Charts while the Boy is Manglik only from Birth Chart , can the marriage be considered wholeheartedly and if yes will it be safe for both the partners and without any ill-effects due to this mangal chart differences.
Also Navneet Sir, If a Girl is Non Manglik from both the charts (Birth as well as Moon) , can a Low Manglik Boy(Birth Chart only) marry her without any ill-effects on the Mangal front….Kindly advice Sir.
Thanks very much for your help ..Kind Regards Umesh
One last point clarification from my end please, if in future I come across a non Manglik proposal (Girl being Non-Manglik) and if the proposal is good , Could the marriage be held and do I have to do any ritual or any procedure to avoid any compatibility issues/ill effects from me being Manglik please…
I can only say after looking at the horoscope of the girl. Before that it is not possible to comment anything. As per my views you should marry a mangalik girl. You also need to understand that mangal dosha check is only one of the many things that are checked in Horoscope matching.
You can read more about Horoscope matching in the article given below