Suggest you contact a local astrologer and get some answer. We on this site will not answer questions like the one you asked without studying it in detail though the answer may be Yes or No. We answer questions for free only for questions which can be answered by a cursory examination. I can answer your question only by studying both horoscopes in detail which will take more than 6 hours of my time.
Read my blog http://www.navagrahastro.blogspot.com and you will get a good insight into how astrological evaluations are done scientifically.